SA government cites ‘safe space’ to withhold Adelaide MotoGP records
Updated: 3 days ago

The South Australian Motor Sport Board has withheld documents about Adelaide’s proposed MotoGP event, arguing it needs a “safe space” to consider options without fear of its advice becoming public.
A freedom of information request by ParklandsFOI sought board agendas, minutes and other papers concerning MotoGP and the redevelopment of the Adelaide Street Circuit in the Adelaide Park Lands.
The board identified 14 documents, refusing access to 10 in full and releasing four sets of heavily redacted minutes.
The released minutes leave little beyond attendance lists and routine meeting business visible. Entire pages are covered by grey boxes. Some external guests’ names and the locations of board meetings were also withheld.
These records could help explain what options and impacts the board considered in planning changes to public Park Lands.
In its determination, received on 7 September, the board acknowledged the public interest in transparent government decision-making but said this was:
“...outweighed by the need for a safe space to consider options without fear of this advice being made public”.
It also argued that disclosure could substantially harm its functions by exposing confidential planning and commercial information. Two documents were additionally withheld under the Cabinet exemption.
Former senator Rex Patrick reported a similar outcome from a separate request about tree removals and permanent structures for MotoGP in the Park Lands. Writing in Michael West Media, he described the documents as “almost completely redacted” and reported the same justification for withholding information.
Greens Legislative Councillor Melanie Selwood described the government’s FOI response as “pathetic” in a social media post.
“...and they wonder why people are so outraged on this issue,” she wrote.
ParklandsFOI sought internal review, arguing that the board had not adequately justified the exemptions or given sufficient weight to the public interest in disclosure. In a letter dated 1 October, SA Motor Sport Board chief executive Mark Warren maintained the refusal.
ParklandsFOI applied to Ombudsman SA for external review on 7 October. That review remains underway.
The Ombudsman has previously rejected similar arguments over Adelaide motorsport records.
In a September 2021 determination, then Ombudsman Wayne Lines rejected the South Australian Tourism Commission’s unsupported claim that disclosure of Adelaide 500 records would inhibit frank advice. The Ombudsman noted:
“significant public interest in the disclosure of any documents which discuss the cancellation of the Adelaide 500”.
Lines also recognised the value of scrutinising government decisions and understanding the alternatives considered. He required further disclosure of the two disputed documents, while upholding some redactions.
The applicant who secured that disclosure was then opposition leader, now Premier, Peter Malinauskas.



Comments