Cut, mill, don’t spill: Persse invokes ‘safe space’ to withhold LIV Golf tree tender documents
Updated: 3 days ago

The Premier’s department is refusing to release draft confidentiality agreements for a project to mill trees felled as part of the $45 million North Adelaide golf course redevelopment.
Rick Persse, chief executive of the Department of the Premier and Cabinet (DPC), argued that disclosure could substantially harm the department’s work and would be contrary to the public interest because government and business need a “safe space” to “explore commercial and social opportunities”.
ParklandsFOI’s freedom of information (FOI) application explicitly excluded information submitted by businesses bidding for the work.
In his internal-review decision, Persse—who is reportedly paid $786,347 a year—withheld two draft agreements and two contract attachments in full. He cited confidentiality and commercial-harm exemptions among his reasons. The department also redacted basic details of the proposed milling project.

The government's controversial Park Lands development has prompted major community protests and a Federal Court challenge. LIV Golf’s global collapse last week raises further questions about the project’s future, with the league entering liquidation after more than US$5 billion (A$7 billion) in Saudi investment.
The Auditor-General has also warned major spending decisions on the project may have lacked the required analysis of costs, benefits, risks and value for money, “reducing transparency and accountability” and increasing the risk of inefficient public spending.
Secrecy before suppliers even saw the job
ParklandsFOI applied for the documents in September after InDaily revealed that companies seeking the milling work had to sign a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) before receiving project details and tender documentation.
Companies that failed to return a completed NDA could be excluded. A government spokesperson told InDaily it was “commonplace” for tender conditions to contain confidentiality provisions.
The InDaily report also prompted SA Greens MLC Melanie Selwood to post a video on social media, calling the NDA requirement “a new level of bureaucratic shadiness”.
An email chain titled “NDA for Prospective Tenderers” shows officials were discussing the confidentiality arrangements by at least 16 January 2026—more than seven months before bids closed.
DPC said parts of the correspondence contained legally privileged advice from the Crown Solicitor.
Public servants’ names hidden
Persse also approved redactions of names and government email addresses throughout routine office correspondence, citing the FOI Act’s personal-affairs exemption.
The SA Ombudsman independently reviews disputed FOI decisions. Former ombudsman Wayne Lines has stated that “a person’s name alone is not in itself their personal affairs”. In another decision, he found that public servants’ names and work email addresses do not become private merely because they identify them in their official roles.
In one instance, a staff member’s name is redacted but their position title is visible. A Google search for the title leads to a public LinkedIn profile identifying the person who appears to hold the role.
Who does a government NDA affect
ParklandsFOI has not seen the NDA used for the milling work. But another department's template, captured in a web archive last year, shows why its wording matters: the bidder promises to protect government information, without the deed imposing the same obligation on the government.
The Department of Infrastructure and Transport's PR115-2 Tenderer’s Deed of Confidentiality says it should be used only when tenderers receive “genuinely confidential information” but that it “will not affect a Freedom of Information Act inquiry”.
That distinction has mattered in previous FOI reviews. In one, former Ombudsman Richard Bingham rejected a confidentiality claim where tender conditions required a business to protect government information. After examining the resulting contract, Bingham found it imposed no obligation of confidence on the government.
Government's “safe space” for “commercial and social opportunities”
Persse also invoked clause 16(1)(a)(iv) of the FOI Act to withhold the documents, arguing that disclosure could have a “substantial adverse effect” on the department’s work.
That exemption sets a high threshold: the expected harm must be sufficiently serious or significant to concern a properly informed reasonable person. Disclosure must also be contrary to the public interest.
Persse wrote that government “agencies and third parties must be afforded the opportunity to explore commercial and social opportunities in a safe space”.
But his written decision did not explain which departmental function would be impaired, how releasing the draft agreements and tender attachments would impair it, or why the harm would be substantial.
ParklandsFOI examined nearly 200 published FOI external-review determinations and identified 31 in which agencies invoked this exemption. It found only two in which former Ombudsman Wayne Lines accepted it, both confined to specific operational information.
One protected a department’s staff-only priority phone number for reporting suspected child abuse. The other protected a council’s username and password for an environmental reporting system.
Even those findings were narrow. In both cases, Ombudsman Lines rejected broader attempts to withhold information under the same exemption.


Comments